
Event Summary: Reflections on the 2026 Utrecht Earth-Space Academy

2026 Utrecht Earth-Space Academy
Training school on 'Transformative Governance for Earth-Space Sustainability’
October 28 - 30, 2026
Copernicus Institute of Sustainable Development, Faculty of Geosciences, Utrecht University

By the ERC PlanetStewards Project, co-organized with the Earth-Space Sustainability (ESS) Network & EU COST Action FOGOS
Event Summary: Reflections on the 2026 Utrecht Earth-Space Academy
Bart Janssen, 17/11/2026
From 28 to 30 October 2026, the ERC PlanetStewards Team at the Copernicus Institute of Sustainable Development, Utrecht University, hosted the first Utrecht Earth-Space Academy on 'Transformative Governance for Earth-Space Sustainability'. Building on the 2024 Earth-Space Symposium, the 2025 workshop on Cosmological Imaginaries and the 2nd Earth-Space Sustainability (ESS) Conference in Leiden earlier this year, the Academy marked a new milestone for the ESS Network: providing the next generation of scholars with new conceptual and methodological tools to address Earth-Space sustainability challenges. Led by the PlanetStewards Project and co-organized with the EU COST Action FOGOS and the ESS network, the training school took place at the University Museum Utrecht. Set beside its historic botanical garden, the venue offered a fitting backdrop for three days of rethinking human-nature relations on Earth and in space.
The Academy brought together 21 early-career researchers as Academy Fellows. The PhD candidates and postdoctoral researchers came from 14 countries and fields spanning space law, astronomy, philosophy, environmental systems analysis, security studies, and science and technology studies. Drawing from interdisciplinary perspectives, the Academy prepared Fellows to:
-
Approach Earth-Space systems from diverse disciplines and knowledge traditions
-
Rethink human-nature relations in view of the Earth-Space paradigm
-
Explore the scientific, cultural, environmental and other values of Earth-Space systems
-
Apply concepts and methods to cases such as dark-sky governance and lunar governance
-
Discuss the role of science-policy interfaces in transformative change towards Earth-Space sustainability
Photo: Barbra Verbij

The first day laid the conceptual foundations, moving from the governance of Earth's commons to the history of the cosmos, the night sky and the search for life beyond Earth. Course director Dr. Xiao-Shan Yap (Principal Investigator of PlanetStewards, Utrecht University) opened the Academy with an introductory lecture on Earth-Space governance, setting out why challenges on Earth and Space need to be addressed in an integrative way as human activities extend beyond our planet. She contextualized Earth-Space sustainability as a future scenario that should guide transformative change, reshaping current mindsets that disconnect Earth from space and that conceptualize sustainability mainly in instrumental terms. Her lecture further presented the Earth-Space systems concept and the corresponding paradigm, aiming to guide governance towards addressing a wider range of values.
Dr. Frank van Laerhoven (Utrecht University) asked which lessons from governing the commons on Earth can travel beyond our planet. He defined commons not only as shared resources, but also as the collective practices and relationships through which they are created, sustained, and governed, from natural resources such as water ice on the Moon to collectively built ones such as the International Space Station. He distinguished three types of commons in space: ‘food basket’ commons from which actors extract, ‘scarce’, rivalrous access to orbital slots, and ‘cesspool’ commons that degrade through pollution, such as orbital debris and Moon dust. He invited Fellows to consider which of Ostrom’s eight design principles, from clear boundaries and monitoring to nested systems, could travel beyond Earth.
Dr. Stamatina Mastorakou (University of Pittsburgh) took Fellows into historical times. Referring to Babylonian cuneiform tablets, including the MUL.APIN series that records the rising and setting of constellations, she showed how astronomical knowledge was recorded and transmitted, and how cosmological imaginaries were embedded in systems of authority, religion and material culture, from ancient Greek models to the Copernican revolution.
Dr. Aditi Saraf (Utrecht University) showed how the dark sky is at once a common heritage that resists private ownership, and a ‘frontier’ of extraction. Using ethnography to study these developments from the ground up, she presented her fieldwork in Hanle, Ladakh. The high-altitude village is home to the Indian Astronomical Observatory and, since 2022, India’s first Dark Sky Reserve, where Changpa pastoralists have been trained as ‘astronomy ambassadors’ and night-sky guides. Her research raises questions about commodifying the night sky, and about astronomy infrastructure as a tool of bordering in a region shaped by military expansion and India-China tensions. Darkness, she showed, is actively produced through lighting rules and constant negotiation with army camps, bikers, and tourism. She closed by asking what European dark-sky initiatives might learn from the Global South.
Photo: Barbra Verbij
Photo: Jeroen Koopman
Photo: Monique Shaw
Photo: Monique Shaw
Photo: Barbra Verbij
Prof. Eduardo Unda-Sanzana (University of Antofagasta) presented on the protection of dark and quiet skies in Chile's Atacama Desert. With the rise of ‘megatelescopes’ such as ESO’s Extremely Large Telescope, the country now hosts a large share of the world’s optical and infrared collecting area. Unda-Sanzana traced how Chile has protected the skies of the Atacama since the 1990s: lighting norms in 1998 and 2012, a 2019 law recognizing artificial light as a pollutant, a proposed constitutional article on the night sky that fell with the rejected 2022 constitution, and national rules from 2023. The proposed INNA industrial project near Paranal showed that threats go beyond light. In response, a 2025 national commission proposed protecting each site’s ‘enabling conditions’, the environmental conditions an observatory needs to operate as designed. The presentation concluded by questioning whether Chile’s approach could inform a global network of priority astronomical sites.
Prof. Inge Loes ten Kate (Utrecht University) closed the first day with astrobiology, the study of the origin, evolution and distribution of life in the universe. Scientists mainly search for life as we know it, carbon-based, while staying open to serendipity. She defined a biosignature as a link between an observation and a biological cause, given some context, and showed why such claims call for caution. Signals such as methane on Mars, phosphine on Venus and dimethyl sulphide on K2-18b turned out to be false positives, while false negatives matter just as much: the Viking missions may even have missed life on Mars. That brought her to planetary protection, and to the question that the Fellows would return to in the Planetary Protection session on the final day: who are we protecting, from what, and why?
Photo: Monique Shaw

The second day began with hands-on work. In two parallel sessions, the Fellows explored cosmological imaginaries, building on the first day's lectures, and observed the night sky through the Stellarium planetarium software, linking the history of astronomy to today's concerns about disappearing dark skies. They then split into two groups, on immediate and broader Earth-Space systems, to start preparing their presentations. In the afternoon, the program turned to the political, legal, and ethical dimensions of Earth-Space systems.
Dr. Katharina Glaab (Norwegian University of Life Sciences) started from the dominant view of space geopolitics, built on sovereignty, strategic rivalry and resource competition, and on the assumption that states pursue the same interests in orbit as on Earth. Yet cooperation in space persists. Using Andøya in northern Norway as a case, she showed how communities and infrastructure tie outer space to places on Earth. Moving beyond both ‘Arctic exceptionalism’ and ‘space exceptionalism’, her message was clear: space politics is made in Earth-Space relations, so bring it back to Earth.
Chris Johnson (International Institute of Air and Space Law, Leiden University) explained why states enter treaties at all: they may be hard to enforce, but they give states a shared reference point to keep negotiating. He showed how international law creates obligations, permissions and prohibitions, and set out the core norms of space law. Responsibility for a single space object can be split between the ‘appropriate state’, the state of registry and the launching state, which makes the system more complicated than it first appears. He then looked towards ‘Moon law’. With new estimates of lunar water ice, future space infrastructure is likely to rely on lunar rather than Earth materials, raising new questions of governance, down to practical needs such as a lunar standard time and gravity model for precise landings.
Dr. Michael Picard (University of Edinburgh) presented on the problem of ‘e-waste from space’. From anti-satellite tests to accidental collisions, debris is accumulating in orbit, yet removing someone else’s defunct satellite requires the permission of its state of registry, and because collisions lack intent, liability is hard to assign. Current solutions rely on satellites burning up in the atmosphere, which creates a new problem. Metals from re-entering spacecraft are already found in around 10% of stratospheric aerosol particles, a share that could reach 50% by 2035, with possible effects on the ozone layer. Picard traced how this pollution moves from outer space into the atmosphere and the oceans, falling through the gaps between separate legal regimes. He argued that the Montreal Protocol, which has shown flexibility in adding new substances, could be adapted to address ablated metals as part of a cohesive Earth-Space governance framework.
Dr. Chelsea Haramia (University of Bonn) asked what we owe to environments in space that may be lifeless. She walked Fellows through the main views of what makes something worthy of respect, from rationality and sentience to life itself, and the challenges each faces. Haramia challenged the ‘life bias’: a sterile world such as Jupiter is no more a failure for not developing life than a whale is for not developing flight. She proposed a moral framework between intrinsic and relational value, built on systemic value, rarity, and uniqueness. Her lecture proved to be interactive, prompting a lively round of follow-up questions.
The final day opened with two parallel sessions on lunar and planetary futures. During Dr. Michael Picard's Moon dust scenario exercise, the Fellows took on stakeholder roles, from heritage advocates and dust scientists to space agency lawyers, insurers and geopolitical analysts, to draft policy positions for a mock UNOOSA working group on a fictional 2032 commercial lunar mining mission. In Prof. Inge Loes ten Kate's Planetary Protection session, Fellows returned to the question raised on the first day, discussing planetary protection and the search for extraterrestrial life in the context of a planned future mission. An open space then let Fellows discuss their own research with the faculty, in the same two groups: immediate Earth-Space systems and broader Earth-Space systems. This led to more informal discussions between Fellows and faculty, as Fellows explored questions from their own research with experts from other fields.
In the afternoon, Dr. John Barentine (Dark Sky Consulting) reflected on the ‘Dark and Quiet Skies’ movement at the interface of science and policy. With ‘New Space’, space activities have shifted from states to private commercial actors, and the first mega constellation launches in 2019 brought the impact on astronomy into sharp focus. He set out the movement’s three pillars: ‘ground-based light pollution’, which is increasing by around 10% per year, ‘radio-frequency interference’, and ‘large satellite constellations’. Satellites and debris leave trails across both ground-based and space telescope observations, and even inactive satellites keep emitting radio signals, threatening fields from cosmic microwave background research to planetary defense. Asked what transformative governance would look like, he argued that astronomy should be treated as co-equal with space exploration, and that the night sky is a commons, held in trust rather than owned, a view which is still widely disputed.
Dr. Jeroen Oomen (Utrecht University) then invited Fellows to break ‘captured futures’ and work towards an Earth-Space imaginary. Futures, he argued, are performative: the way a future is presented prompts certain actions. He offered three views for analyzing visions of the future: storylines, dramaturgy and structure. To govern something, it must first be defined as a distinct object that people care about governing. This left the Fellows with a question to take into their group presentations: what would it mean to make ‘Earth-Space’ a new object of governance?
The Academy closed with the group presentations, which brought together the concepts and methods of the three days. Each group first constructed its own Earth-Space system: identifying the sustainability concerns and values at stake, drawing its boundaries, and reflecting on how different cosmologies shape where those boundaries lie. They then worked towards consensus on how to address these problems, weighing trade-offs, proposing sustainability indicators and asking what needs to change in current governance to achieve transformative outcomes. The groups were free to present in any form, and one chose an artistic route, staging a short play, while the other provided a panel-based discussion.
Across the three days, many speakers questioned how far Earth-based frameworks, from commons governance to environmental and space law, can travel beyond our planet, and where new thinking is needed. Dark and quiet skies emerged as a recurring meeting point, from Ladakh and the Atacama Desert to orbit and broader space, showing why Earth and Space sustainability cannot be addressed separately. And from Indigenous cosmologies to the moral value of lifeless worlds, Fellows were repeatedly invited to rethink not only how we govern Earth-Space systems, but also what we value in them. Besides the content, one of the Academy's most valued outcomes was the opportunity for Fellows to meet peers from across disciplines and countries, and gain insight into fields far from their own.
As Earth-Space sustainability moves from an emerging concept towards concrete needs for governance, the next challenge is to turn these conversations into frameworks and collaborations. The PlanetStewards Project will continue to advance this research agenda, and we look forward to further exchange with the 2026 Academy Fellows through the Earth-Space Sustainability Network. We thank all lecturers, Fellows, and the University Museum Utrecht for making the Academy possible.
Photos:
Berfin Deniz Çabuk
































